Log or Linear? Distinct Intuitions of the Number Scale

Posted by Bayle Shanks at 8:25 PM EST

Stanislas Dehaene, VĂ©ronique Izard, Elizabeth Spelke, and Pierre Pica. Log or linear? Distinct intuitions of the number scale in Western and Amazonian indigene cultures. Science, 320(5880):1217–1220, May 2008.

The Mundurucu are an indigenous culture whose language does not contain exact words for numbers above 5. Dehaene, Izard, Spelke, and Pica basically gave subjects an empty horizontal line and then gave them a bunch of numbers and told them to place the numbers where they belong on the line (the line was not entirely empty; the left and right hand sides were labeled with a small number and a big number).

Western adults tend to place the numbers linearly, whereas the Mundurucu tend to place them logarithmically. Western children also place them logarithmically, and even Western adults place them logarithmically if the numbers are presented as larger numbers of dots (10-100) or if they are presented as tones.

This suggests that there is an innate logarithmic representation of number which is used to populate the number line, but that with training a linear representation can be created.

One Response to “Log or Linear? Distinct Intuitions of the Number Scale”

  1. Amiya Sarkar Says:

    Interesting study on how logarithm scale functions across ethnic populations. In fact, we hear in a log scale rather than a linear scale.

Leave a Reply

 

Additional comments powered by BackType

  • nd categories

  • contact us

    Neurodudes is moderated by Neville Sanjana, Bayle Shanks, and Stephen Larson. Comments that you post might be delayed so that we can tell our software that it's not spam -- however, not all comments are pre-screened so don't assume that we have read them, either. Any money we make off this site is used to pay for hosting, or given to charity; if in the future we pay contributors, we will include reader-authors. None of us are medical doctors so please don't ask for medical advice. Contact us here.