neurodudes » Blog Archive » The Third Reviewer

The Third Reviewer

Posted by Bayle Shanks at 8:58 PM EST

”
Neuroscientists love talking about recent papers (lambasting, exalting), but currently the options for doing this online are bad. You have to log in, with your real name, at whichever journal published the paper. So you’re not going to write anything critical, lest the author be angry at you, nor are you going to go back and follow it up, because it’s such a hassle to find the paper again on the journal site. Enter The Third Reviewer.

It’s a centralized commenting location for all major neuroscience papers. Every recently published paper has a page that you can find by browsing or searching. You can leave comments anonymously, and you can request follow-up emails when others comment. ThirdReviewer currently indexes all papers from 11 major journals, including Neuron, Nature, J Neurosci, and Nature Neuroscience.

Check it out and opine: The Third Reviewer
“

This entry was posted on Wednesday, June 23rd, 2010 at 8:58 pm by Bayle Shanks and is filed under Discussion, Internet and blogs. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

2 Responses to “The Third Reviewer”

masaru Says:
June 24th, 2010 at 3:52 am
It seems that The third reviewer doesn’t require logging in.
masaru Says:
June 24th, 2010 at 3:53 am
to comment.

Leave a Reply

Additional comments powered by BackType

Feeds are periodically added and subtracted, but hopefully reflects the blogrolls below (but doesn't yet -- it's still under construction), except for those feeds which Yahoo Pipes had trouble processing, a list of which can be seen by checking the Pipe page.

Bayle's working on Google Reader bundles for neuroscience journals, and other neuro feeds. Like the Ultimate Neurodudes Feed, these are heavily under construction, and probably aren't very good yet.

Here's a neurodudes' friend feed on Twitter, which follows a bunch of people who often post interesting material.

more

See our links page.

nd categories

Artificial intelligence (50)
- Robotics (21)
At the scale of cells and synapses (87)
- Computation within single neurons (21)
- Genetics and molecular (52)
- Ion channels (22)
- Neuronal arbors/neurites (18)
  - Axons (7)
  - Dendrites (11)
  - Synapses (1)
At the scale of one or more individuals (63)
- Animal cognition (19)
- Evolution (28)
- Neuroeconomics (9)
- Neuroethics (8)
- Neuroethology (16)
At the scale of systems and functions (152)
- Connectivity (1)
- Cortex (10)
- Memory and learning (55)
  - Cellular learning (13)
  - Learning theory (11)
  - Memory systems (32)
- Motor systems (14)
- Pathologies (5)
- Rhythms and oscillations (2)
- Sleep (11)
- Vision (19)
Cognitive science (84)
- Consciousness / NCC (20)
- Language (16)
Computational neuroscience (77)
- Data analysis (7)
- Neural network models (31)
Development and healing (25)
- Neural development (12)
- Neural regeneration/neurogenesis (16)
- Neuroanatomy (4)
Fun (1)
Interdisciplinary concepts (38)
- Biological computation (in non-neural systems) (13)
- Distributed/Parallel Computation (8)
- Networks (12)
  - Social networks and organizations (10)
- Probabilistic models (6)
Medicine and other intervention/augmentation (106)
- Brain-machine interfaces (47)
  - Neural prosthetics (26)
- Consumer neurotechnology (2)
- Medicine (34)
- Neuroengineering (8)
- Neuropharmacology (32)
  - neuropharmacology-comments-excluded-from-frontpage (2)
Methods and techniques (103)
- Biophysics (15)
- Culture (in vitro) (15)
- Genetic (4)
- Imaging (29)
- Multi-electode arrays (14)
- Software and online tools (8)
Misc (50)
- Uncategorized (18)
Neurodudes (meta) (6)
News, conferences, books, jobs, etc (118)
- Book review (7)
- Business (7)
- Cog/neuro science careers (26)
- Conferences (43)
- Education (21)
- Grants (6)
- Internet and blogs (24)
- Jobs (2)
Secondary post categories (42)
- Discussion (34)
- Policy (2)
- Review article (7)
Systems biology (5)
Theory/Philosophy (17)

contact us

Neurodudes is moderated by Neville Sanjana, Bayle Shanks, and Stephen Larson. Comments that you post might be delayed so that we can tell our software that it's not spam -- however, not all comments are pre-screened so don't assume that we have read them, either. Any money we make off this site is used to pay for hosting, or given to charity; if in the future we pay contributors, we will include reader-authors. None of us are medical doctors so please don't ask for medical advice. Contact us here.

wordpress counter